Congratulations to Jeff, who wins the $50 gift certificate to Pewter Rose!!
Jeff proves that persistence pays off -- he posted 14 halloween costume comments on our post.
To pick a winner, we used Random.org to generate a random integer. The magic number was "21." So comment 21 was the winning post:
pig in a blanket (cop wrapped in a blanket)
Thanks to all who played! You guys had some great costume ideas!